How to Prepare Your Daughter for High School Softball

A Coach's Guide to Making the Team, Understanding Tryouts, and Preparing for the Next Level

Making a high school softball team is an exciting milestone for young athletes. But for many players and parents, the transition from recreational or travel softball to high school competition brings a lot of questions.

Is my daughter good enough to make the team? What are high school coaches looking for? Does she need to play travel softball? Should she start preparing in seventh or eighth grade?

After years of coaching competitive travel softball, I've worked with players at different stages of development. One thing I've learned is that being a successful travel ball player doesn't automatically guarantee success in high school softball.

High school coaches evaluate more than batting averages, home runs, and the name of your travel organization. They're looking for athletes who can contribute to their program, execute fundamentals, compete consistently, and become dependable teammates.

At SBX Fastpitch, we believe preparing for high school softball starts well before tryouts.

Here's what players and parents should understand about making the transition.

---

1. When Should Girls Start Preparing for High School Softball?

For most athletes, seventh and eighth grade are excellent times to begin preparing more intentionally for high school softball.

That doesn't mean younger players shouldn't develop their skills. It simply means that as high school approaches, training should become more focused.

By 12U and 14U, athletes should begin developing the fundamentals, athleticism, and confidence necessary to compete against older and more experienced players.

What Should Players Focus On Before High School?

• Consistent throwing mechanics
• Reliable defensive fundamentals
• A repeatable hitting approach
• Understanding game situations
• Developing speed and athleticism
• Learning multiple defensive positions
• Building mental toughness
• Developing strong practice habits

My coaching perspective:

I wouldn't spend seventh and eighth grade worrying about whether a player will make varsity as a freshman.

I'd focus on making sure she's developing the skills necessary to compete when she gets there.

Some athletes are physically ready for varsity at 14 years old. Others need time to develop through freshman or junior varsity softball.

Both paths can lead to successful high school careers.

2. What Do High School Softball Coaches Look for During Tryouts?

Every high school program is different.

Some schools have highly competitive varsity teams with several college-level prospects. Others have smaller programs where athletes have more opportunities to develop.

However, most high school coaches evaluate several common areas.

Defensive Fundamentals

Coaches want players who can consistently make routine plays.

For infielders, this includes:

• Proper fielding mechanics
• Efficient footwork
• Accurate throws
• Quick transfers
• Understanding defensive responsibilities

For outfielders:

• Reading fly balls
• Taking efficient routes
• Catching the ball consistently
• Making accurate throws
• Understanding where to throw the ball

A player doesn't need to make spectacular defensive plays to impress a coach.

Being dependable on routine plays is often more valuable than occasionally making an exceptional play.

Hitting Ability

High school coaches evaluate more than whether a player gets a hit during tryouts.

They're looking at:

• Swing mechanics
• Bat speed
• Contact quality
• Balance
• Timing
• Ability to make adjustments
• Approach against different pitching speeds

A player who hits several hard line drives directly at defenders may demonstrate more offensive potential than someone who reaches base on weak contact.

Throwing Ability

Throwing is one of the most important skills in softball.

Coaches evaluate arm strength, accuracy, mechanics, and how efficiently a player transfers the ball.

A strong arm is valuable, but accuracy and consistency are equally important.

Athleticism

Speed, coordination, balance, and overall movement can separate players during tryouts.

Athleticism also helps coaches identify players who may be capable of developing at multiple positions.

Coachability

This is something I believe parents sometimes underestimate.

How does your daughter respond when a coach corrects her?

Does she listen?

Does she attempt to make the adjustment?

Does she become frustrated or defensive?

Coaches want athletes who are willing to learn.

Attitude and Effort

Coaches notice how players carry themselves.

They observe whether athletes hustle, communicate, support teammates, and remain engaged.

A player's attitude can influence how a coach evaluates her potential contribution to the team.

---

3. Does My Daughter Need to Play Travel Ball to Make Her High School Team?

No. Travel softball is not a requirement for playing high school softball.

However, competitive travel softball can provide valuable experience.

Travel ball often exposes players to:

• Stronger pitching
• Faster defensive play
• More competitive tournaments
• Advanced game situations
• Position-specific instruction
• Greater expectations for preparation

That experience can help players adjust to high school competition.

But not every travel program provides the same level of development.

Travel Ball Experience vs. Actual Ability

I've always believed that the quality of coaching and player development matters more than the organization printed on the jersey.

A player from a smaller travel program with excellent fundamentals may be better prepared than an athlete from a nationally recognized organization who hasn't developed consistent skills.

High school coaches are evaluating the player standing in front of them.

Not the reputation of her travel team.

My coaching advice: Focus on becoming a better softball player rather than simply joining a bigger-name organization.

---

4. What Skills Should a 14U Player Have Before High School?

By the time a player enters high school, she should ideally have a solid foundation in the game's fundamentals.

That doesn't mean every incoming freshman needs varsity-level skills.

But there are several areas I would prioritize.

Throwing

Players should be developing the ability to throw accurately and consistently from their primary defensive positions.

They should understand proper footwork and how to generate momentum toward their target.

Fielding

Players should be comfortable fielding routine ground balls, catching fly balls, and making basic defensive decisions.

The ability to consistently execute routine plays is essential.

Hitting

Players should have a repeatable swing and enough bat control to compete against age-appropriate pitching.

They should also begin understanding pitch selection, timing, and situational hitting.

Baserunning

Players should understand:

• Proper leads when permitted
• Rounding bases
• Tagging up
• Reading balls in the dirt
• Recognizing defensive mistakes
• Making aggressive but intelligent decisions

Game Awareness

Players should understand common defensive situations without needing constant instruction.

For example, with a runner on first and one out, an infielder should know the likely force-play opportunities before the ball is hit.

Communication

Players should be comfortable calling for fly balls, communicating defensive responsibilities, and supporting teammates.

My coaching perspective:

At 14U, I want athletes to start thinking ahead.

They shouldn't wait until the ball is hit to figure out what they're supposed to do.

---

5. Should My Daughter Specialize in One Position Before High School?

This is an important question, particularly for 12U and 14U families.

My recommendation is to develop a primary position while maintaining the ability to play at least one additional position.

For example:

• Shortstop / Second Base
• Third Base / First Base
• First Base / Outfield
• Second Base / Outfield
• Catcher / Third Base

Pitchers and catchers may require additional specialized training, but developing broader athletic and defensive skills can still be valuable.

Why Versatility Matters

High school coaches build rosters based on team needs.

A player who can competently play multiple positions may provide more roster flexibility.

For example, a coach might already have an established third baseman but need another outfielder.

If your daughter can play both positions, she may have additional opportunities to contribute.

My Coaching Advice

Don't limit a young athlete too early.

A player who excels at shortstop at 10U may eventually develop into an excellent third baseman, outfielder, or catcher.

As players mature, their physical abilities and team needs can change.

Versatility creates opportunities.

---

6. How Important Is Hitting for Making a High School Team?

Hitting is an important part of player evaluation.

However, high school coaches aren't necessarily looking for every athlete to hit home runs.

Different players bring different offensive strengths.

Some are power hitters.

Others excel at making consistent contact, using their speed, or executing situational offense.

What Coaches Evaluate

Swing Mechanics: Does the player have a repeatable swing?

Bat Speed: Can she generate enough bat speed to compete against high school pitching?

Contact Quality: Is she consistently hitting the ball hard?

Timing: Can she adjust to different pitching speeds?

Approach: Does she understand the strike zone and recognize pitches?

Adjustability: Can she make corrections when something isn't working?

My Coaching Advice

One of the biggest mistakes players make during tryouts is trying to do too much.

They want to impress the coach, so they start swinging harder, changing their mechanics, or trying to hit every ball over the fence.

I'd rather see a hitter stay within her approach and consistently make quality contact.

A controlled, repeatable swing is more valuable than an occasional big hit surrounded by poor at-bats.

---

7. How Can My Daughter Improve Her Chances of Making Varsity?

This is a question many parents ask before their daughter enters high school.

The answer depends heavily on the competitiveness of the program.

At some schools, freshmen regularly contribute to varsity.

At others, varsity rosters are filled with experienced juniors and seniors.

What Helps Players Compete for Varsity?

• Strong defensive fundamentals
• Consistent offensive ability
• Good athleticism
• Understanding game situations
• Position versatility
• Mental maturity
• Coachability
• Ability to compete against older athletes

Should My Daughter Be Disappointed If She Makes JV?

No.

Junior varsity can provide valuable opportunities for development.

Players may receive more playing time, build confidence, and continue improving before moving to varsity.

A freshman who plays regularly on JV may gain more developmental experience than one who rarely enters games on varsity.

That doesn't mean JV is always the better choice. It depends on the athlete and the program.

My Coaching Advice

Parents should avoid treating varsity as the only measure of success.

The goal should be developing into the best player possible over four years.

Where your daughter starts her high school career doesn't determine where she'll finish.

---

8. How Many Days a Week Should My Daughter Practice Before High School Tryouts?

Consistency is important, but players don't need to practice softball every day.

A productive training schedule should balance skill development, athletic training, competition, and recovery.

For a healthy 13- or 14-year-old, a sample week without games might look like this:

This is an example, not a required schedule. During tournament weeks, additional skill sessions should often be reduced.

What Should Players Prioritize?

If your daughter has limited training time, focus on her greatest developmental needs.

For example:

If she's struggling defensively: Prioritize footwork, glove work, and throwing accuracy.

If she's struggling offensively: Focus on swing mechanics, timing, and quality contact.

If she's lacking athleticism: Consider age-appropriate strength, coordination, and speed training.

If she's struggling mentally: Work on preparation, confidence, and responding to mistakes.

My Coaching Advice

I don't believe in practicing simply to say you practiced.

Every training session should have a purpose.

If your daughter needs to improve her throwing accuracy, spending another hour taking random swings isn't necessarily the best use of her time.

Identify the weakness. Build a plan. Measure improvement.

---

9. How to Prepare for High School Softball Tryouts

Preparing for tryouts should begin weeks or months in advance—not the night before.

Here are several things I recommend.

Understand the Program

Research the high school softball program your daughter plans to attend.

Look at:

• Varsity and JV teams
• Coaching staff
• Program expectations
• Recent competition level
• Available preseason opportunities
• Tryout dates and requirements

Some programs offer summer camps or preseason conditioning opportunities.

When available and appropriate, these can help players become familiar with the program.

Practice Fundamental Skills

Before tryouts, prioritize:

• Throwing accuracy
• Routine ground balls
• Fly balls
• Hitting fundamentals
• Baserunning
• Defensive communication

Players should feel confident performing basic skills.

Prepare Physically

Athletes should arrive at tryouts reasonably conditioned for the activities they'll perform.

That doesn't mean starting an intense training program the week before.

Conditioning should be developed gradually.

Get Proper Rest

Sleep and recovery are important.

Avoid exhausting training sessions immediately before tryouts.

Bring the Right Equipment

Players should arrive with:

• Softball glove
• Bat
• Batting helmet
• Cleats
• Appropriate athletic clothing
• Water
• Any additional equipment required by the school

Catchers should confirm whether they need to bring their own catching equipment.

Arrive Early

Arriving early allows athletes to warm up, become comfortable, and prepare mentally.

Being late creates unnecessary stress and may leave a poor impression.

---

10. What Should My Daughter Do During High School Tryouts?

Tryouts can be stressful, especially for incoming freshmen.

Players naturally want to impress coaches.

However, trying too hard can sometimes lead to mistakes.

Hustle Between Drills

Coaches notice effort.

Run on and off the field, stay engaged, and be ready when it's your turn.

Communicate

Call for fly balls.

Communicate with teammates.

Demonstrate awareness during defensive drills.

Listen to Instructions

Pay attention when coaches explain drills.

If something isn't clear, ask an appropriate question.

Respond Positively to Corrections

If a coach provides feedback, acknowledge it and attempt to make the adjustment.

Don't Dwell on Mistakes

Everyone makes mistakes during tryouts.

What matters is how you respond.

A player who makes an error and immediately refocuses demonstrates maturity.

Be a Good Teammate

Encourage other players.

Help collect equipment.

Stay engaged even when you're not participating in a drill.

My Coaching Advice

One of the things I notice when evaluating players is how they behave when they aren't the center of attention.

Are they watching?

Are they listening?

Are they supporting teammates?

Or are they distracted and disengaged?

Coaches are evaluating athletes throughout the tryout—not just when they're hitting or fielding.

---

11. Common Mistakes Parents Make Before High School Softball

Parents want to give their daughters every opportunity to succeed.

However, some well-intentioned decisions can create unnecessary pressure.

Comparing Their Daughter to Other Players

Every athlete develops differently.

Physical maturity, confidence, coordination, and experience can create significant differences between players of the same age.

Focusing Only on Varsity

Making varsity as a freshman can be exciting, but it shouldn't define a player's high school career.

Overloading the Training Schedule

More practices and lessons don't automatically produce better results.

Fatigue and overtraining can negatively affect performance.

Trying to Control the Tryout Process

Parents should support their daughters, but athletes need to learn how to communicate with coaches and handle evaluations independently.

Blaming Coaches for Every Setback

Not every roster decision will go the way a family hopes.

Sometimes a player needs more development.

Other times, the team's needs simply don't align with her current strengths.

Learning how to respond constructively is part of becoming a competitive athlete.

My Coaching Advice

Parents can provide encouragement, opportunities, and support.

But ultimately, the athlete needs to take ownership of her development.

The goal isn't to make every decision for your daughter. It's to help her become confident enough to make decisions for herself.

---

12. What If My Daughter Doesn't Make the High School Team?

Not making a high school team can be disappointing.

But it doesn't necessarily mean a player's softball career is over.

If your daughter doesn't make the team, encourage her to seek constructive feedback when appropriate.

Ask what specific areas she should improve.

Then create a development plan.

Possible Next Steps

• Continue playing recreational or travel softball
• Work on identified skill weaknesses
• Improve overall athleticism
• Attend appropriate camps or clinics
• Develop additional defensive positions
• Prepare for the following year's tryouts

The important thing is maintaining perspective.

A single tryout doesn't define an athlete's potential.

My Coaching Advice

I've seen players make significant improvements over relatively short periods when they become focused on their development.

Sometimes disappointment becomes motivation.

However, that motivation needs to come from the athlete.

Parents should provide support without turning the experience into additional pressure.

---

13. Does High School Softball Matter for College Recruiting?

Yes, high school softball can be an important part of an athlete's development and recruiting profile.

However, college coaches evaluate athletes through multiple channels, including:

• Travel softball tournaments
• College camps
• High school competition
• Skills videos
• Direct communication
• Academic information

For athletes pursuing college softball, playing on a competitive travel team may provide additional opportunities to compete in front of college coaches.

But the athlete's abilities and academic qualifications remain essential.

Should Freshmen Already Be Thinking About College Softball?

Players who have college aspirations can begin learning about the recruiting process early.

However, freshmen shouldn't feel pressured to have their college future figured out.

The early high school years are an excellent time to focus on skill development, academics, and exploring potential college interests.

NCAA recruiting rules vary by division and sport, so families should consult current NCAA guidance before contacting coaches or planning recruiting activities.

My Coaching Advice

If your daughter wants to play college softball, the best thing she can do early in high school is become a better player and a strong student.

Recruiting exposure matters, but development comes first.

Focus on becoming a college-level athlete before worrying about getting recruited.

---

14. Frequently Asked Questions About High School Softball

Can a freshman make varsity softball?

Yes. Some freshmen earn varsity roster spots, depending on their abilities and the competitiveness of the program.

Do you have to play travel softball to make high school softball?

No. Travel softball is not required, although it can provide valuable competitive experience and development opportunities.

What should a 14U player know before high school?

Players should have a solid foundation in throwing, fielding, hitting, baserunning, and game awareness.

How competitive are high school softball tryouts?

Competition varies significantly by school. Some programs have large numbers of experienced players competing for limited roster spots.

Should my daughter play JV or varsity as a freshman?

The best placement depends on her abilities, available playing opportunities, and the program's structure.

Both can provide valuable experiences.

What do coaches look for during softball tryouts?

Coaches commonly evaluate fundamentals, athleticism, hitting, throwing, game awareness, coachability, effort, and attitude.

How can my daughter stand out at tryouts?

Demonstrate reliable fundamentals, hustle, communicate, listen to coaching, and respond positively to mistakes.

What if my daughter doesn't make the team?

Encourage her to seek feedback, identify development priorities, and continue improving if she wants to pursue softball.